cyber vulnerabilities to dod systems may include

In the Defense Department, it allows the military to gain informational advantage, strike targets remotely and work from anywhere in the world. But given the interdependent and networked nature of multiple independent weapons systems, merely assessing individual platforms misses crucial potential vulnerabilities that may arise when platforms interact with one another. While the United States has ostensibly deterred strategic cyberattacks above the threshold of armed conflict, it has failed to create sufficient costs for adversaries below that threshold in a way that would shape adversary behavior in a desired direction.1 Effectively, this tide of malicious behavior represents a deterrence failure for strategic cyber campaigns below the use-of-force threshold; threat actors have not been dissuaded from these types of campaigns because they have not perceived that the costs or risks of conducting them outweigh the benefits.2 This breakdown has led to systemic and pervasive efforts by adversaries to leverage U.S. vulnerabilities and its large attack surface in cyberspace to conduct intellectual property theftincluding critical national security intellectual propertyat scale, use cyberspace in support of information operations that undermine Americas democratic institutions, and hold at risk the critical infrastructure that sustains the U.S. economy, national security, and way of life. 3 (2017), 454455. 6395, 116th Cong., 2nd sess., 1940. 3 (January 2017), 45. This website uses cookies to help personalize and improve your experience. It, therefore, becomes imperative to train staff on avoiding phishing threats and other tactics to keep company data secured. The attacker is also limited to the commands allowed for the currently logged-in operator. 24 Michael P. Fischerkeller and Richard J. Harknett, Deterrence Is Not a Credible Strategy for Cyberspace, Orbis 61, no. An attacker will attempt to take over a machine and wait for the legitimate user to VPN into the control system LAN and piggyback on the connection. 34 See, for example, Emily O. Goldman and Michael Warner, Why a Digital Pearl Harbor Makes Sense . 1981); Lawrence D. Freedman and Jeffrey Michaels. This not only helps keep hackers out, it isolates the control system network from outages, worms, and other afflictions that occur on the business LAN. They decided to outsource such expertise from the MAD Security team and without input, the company successfully achieved a measurable cyber risk reduction. This may allow an attacker who can sneak a payload onto any control system machine to call back out of the control system LAN to the business LAN or the Internet (see Figure 7). And, if deterrence fails, cyber operations to disrupt or degrade the functioning of kinetic weapons systems could compromise mission assurance during crises and conflicts. These applications can result in real-time operational control adjustments, reports, alarms and events, calculated data source for the master database server archival, or support of real-time analysis work being performed from the engineering workstation or other interface computers. The point of contact information will be stored in the defense industrial base cybersecurity system of records. Ibid., 25. Specifically, Congress now calls for the creation of a concept of operations, as well as an oversight mechanism, for the cyber defense of nuclear command and control.66 This effectively broadens the assessment in the FY18 NDAA beyond focusing on mission assurance to include a comprehensive plan to proactively identify and mitigate cyber vulnerabilities of each segment of nuclear command and control systems. Joint Force Quarterly 102. However, adversaries could compromise the integrity of command and control systemsmost concerningly for nuclear weaponswithout exploiting technical vulnerabilities in the digital infrastructure on which these systems rely. 3 (2017), 454455. The department will do this by: Vice Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, Four Pillars U.S. National Cyber Strategy, Hosted by Defense Media Activity - WEB.mil. 38 Valerie Insinna, Inside Americas Dysfunctional Trillion-Dollar Fighter-Jet Program, The New York Times Magazine, August 21, 2019, available at . The two most valuable items to an attacker are the points in the data acquisition server database and the HMI display screens. Past congressional action has spurred some important progress on this issue. Control systems are vulnerable to cyber attack from inside and outside the control system network. 51 Office of Inspector General, Progress and Challenges in Securing the Nations Cyberspace (Washington, DC: Department of Homeland Security, July 2004), 136, available at . An attacker that just wants to shut down a process needs very little discovery. Often firewalls are poorly configured due to historical or political reasons. On October 9th, 2018, the United States Government Accountability Office (GAO) published a report to the Senate that details the cybersecurity vulnerabilities of the Department of Defense's (DOD) weapon systems. Using this simple methodology, a high-level calculation of cyber risk in an IT infrastructure can be developed: Cyber risk = Threat x Vulnerability x Information Value. The types of data include data from the following sources: the data acquisition server, operator control interactions, alarms and events, and calculated and generated from other sources. 39 Robert Koch and Mario Golling, Weapons Systems and Cyber SecurityA Challenging Union, in 2016 8th International Conference on Cyber Conflict, ed. 59 These include implementing defend forward, which plays an important role in addressing one aspect of this challenge. Building dependable partnerships with private-sector entities who are vital to helping support military operations. Prior to the 2018 strategy, defending its networks had been DODs primary focus; see The DOD Cyber Strategy (Washington, DC: DOD, April 2015), available at . Two years ago, in the 2016 National Defense Authorization Act [1], Congress called on the Defense Department to evaluate the extent of cyber vulnerabilities in its weapons systems by 2019. There are a number of common ways an attacker can gain access, but the miscellaneous pathways outnumber the common pathways. By far the most common architecture is the two-firewall architecture (see Figure 3). . The added strength of a data DMZ is dependent on the specifics of how it is implemented. Encuentro Cuerpo Consular de Latinoamerica - Mesa de Concertacin MHLA This articles discussion of credibility focuses on how cyber operations could undermine the credibility of conventional and nuclear deterrence, rather than the challenge of how to establish credible deterrence using cyber capabilities. See also Martin C. Libicki, David Senty, and Julia Pollak, Hackers Wanted: An Examination of the Cybersecurity Labor Market (Santa Monica, CA: RAND, 2014), x; Julian Jang-Jaccard and Surya Nepal, A Survey of Emerging Threats in Cybersecurity, Journal of Computer and System Sciences 80, no. 6 Office of the Secretary of Defense, Annual Report to Congress: Military and Security Developments Involving the Peoples Republic of China 2020 (Washington, DC: DOD, 2020). Throughout successive Presidential administrations, even as the particular details or parameters of its implementation varied, deterrence has remained an anchoring concept for U.S. strategy.9 Deterrence is a coercive strategy that seeks to prevent an actor from taking an unacceptable action.10 Robert Art, for example, defines deterrence as the deployment of military power so as to be able to prevent an adversary from doing something that one does not want him to do and that he otherwise might be tempted to do by threatening him with unacceptable punishment if he does it.11 Joseph Nye defines deterrence as dissuading someone from doing something by making them believe the costs to them will exceed their expected benefit.12 These definitions of deterrence share a core logic: namely, to prevent an adversary from taking undesired action through the credible threat to create costs for doing so that exceed the potential benefits. In this way, cyber vulnerabilities that adversaries exploit in routine competition below the level of war have dangerous implications for the U.S. ability to deter and prevail in conflict above that thresholdeven in a noncyber context. Special vulnerabilities of AI systems. systems. Nearly all modern databases allow this type of attack if not configured properly to block it. For example, there is no permanent process to periodically assess the vulnerability of fielded systems, despite the fact that the threat environment is dynamic and vulnerabilities are not constant. Wireless access points that allow unauthorized connection to system components and networks present vulnerabilities. Around 68% of companies have been said to experience at least one endpoint attack that compromised their data or infrastructure. If deterrence fails in times of crisis and conflict, the United States must be able to defend and surge conventional capabilities when adversaries utilize cyber capabilities to attack American military systems and functions. Cyber threat activity recommended to be submitted as a voluntary report includes but is not limited to: Suspected Advance Persistent Threat (APT) activity; Compromise not impacting DoD information Based on this analysis, this capability could proactively conduct threat-hunting against those identified networks and assets to seek evidence of compromise, identify vulnerabilities, and deploy countermeasures to enable early warning and thwart adversary action. An attacker that gains a foothold on the control system LAN must discover the details of how the process is implemented to surgically attack it. Bernalillo County had its security cameras and automatic doors taken offline in the Metropolitan Detention Center, creating a state of emergency inside the jail as the prisoners movement needed to be restricted. 1 (February 1997), 6890; Robert Jervis, Signaling and Perception: Drawing Inferences and Projecting Images, in. How Do I Choose A Cybersecurity Service Provider? As weapon systems become more software- and IT-dependent and more networked, they actually become more vulnerable to cyber-invasion. The objective would be to improve the overall resilience of the systems as well as to identify secondary and tertiary dependencies, with a focus on rapid remediation of identified vulnerabilities. Its worth noting, however, that ransomware insurance can have certain limitations contractors should be aware of. George Perkovich and Ariel E. Levite (Washington, DC: Georgetown University Press, 2017), 147157; and Justin Sherman, How the U.S. Can Prevent the Next Cyber 9/11,, https://www.wired.com/story/how-the-us-can-prevent-the-next-cyber-911/. Deterrence postures that rely on the credible, reliable, and effective threat to employ conventional or nuclear capabilities could be undermined through adversary cyber operations. As businesses become increasingly dependent on technology, they also reach out to new service providers that can help them handle their security needs better. But where should you start? Nearly every production control system logs to a database on the control system LAN that is then mirrored into the business LAN. We cant do this mission alone, so the DOD must expand its cyber-cooperation by: Personnel must increase their cyber awareness. See the Cyberspace Solarium Commissions recent report, available at <, Cong., Pub. An attacker can modify packets in transit, providing both a full spoof of the operator HMI displays and full control of the control system (see Figure 16). They generally accept any properly formatted command. See National Science Board, Overview of the State of the U.S. S&E Enterprise in a Global Context, in. That means a thorough strategy is needed to preserve U.S. cyberspace superiority and stop cyberattacks before they hit our networks. This could take place in positive or negative formsin other words, perpetrating information as a means to induce operations to erroneously make a decision to employ a capability or to refrain from carrying out a lawful order. The Department of Defense (DOD) strategic concept of defend forward and U.S. Cyber Commands concept of persistent engagement are largely directed toward this latter challenge. Each control system vendor calls the database something different, but nearly every control system assigns each sensor, pump, breaker, etc., a unique number. 12 Joseph S. Nye, Jr., Deterrence and Dissuasion in Cyberspace, International Security 41, no. 20 See, for example, Eric Heginbotham et al., The U.S.-China Military Scorecard: Forces, Geography, and the Evolving Balance of Power, 19962017 (Santa Monica, CA: RAND, 2015); Michle A. Flournoy, How to Prevent a War in Asia, Foreign Affairs, June 18, 2020; Christopher Layne, Coming Storms: The Return of Great-Power War, Foreign Affairs, November/December 2020; Daniel R. Coats, Worldwide Threat Assessment of the U.S. Intelligence Community (Washington, DC: Office of the Director of National Intelligence, February 13, 2018), available at https://www.dni.gov/files/documents/Newsroom/Testimonies/2018-ATA---Unclassified-SSCI.pdf. As Jacquelyn Schneider notes, this type of deterrence involves the use of punishment or denial across domains of warfighting and foreign policy to deter adversaries from utilizing cyber operations to create physical or virtual effects.31 The literature has also examined the inverse aspect of cross-domain deterrencenamely, how threats in the cyber domain can generate instability and risk for deterrence across other domains. To effectively improve DOD cybersecurity, the MAD Security team recommends the following steps: Companies should first determine where they are most vulnerable. Rather, most modern weapons systems comprise a complex set of systemssystems of systems that entail operat[ing] multiple platforms and systems in a collaborate manner to perform military missions.48 An example is the Aegis weapon system, which contains a variety of integrated subsystems, including detection, command and control, targeting, and kinetic capabilities.49 Therefore, vulnerability assessments that focus on individual platforms are unable to identify potential vulnerabilities that may arise when these capabilities interact or work together as part of a broader, networked platform. This means that a singular static assessment is unlikely to capture how vulnerabilities may evolve and change over time.43 Relatedly, a 2018 Government Accountability Office report found pervasive and significant mission-critical vulnerabilities across most weapons systems already under development.44 Between 2012 and 2017, DOD penetration testersindividuals who evaluate the cybersecurity of computer systems and uncover vulnerabilitiesdiscovered mission-critical cyber vulnerabilities in nearly all weapon systems under development.45 Penetration testing teams were able to overcome weapons systems cybersecurity controls designed to prevent determined adversaries from gaining access to these platforms and to maneuver within compromised systems while successfully evading detection. 35 Relatedly, adversary campaigns to conduct cyber-enabled intellectual property theft against the U.S. military and the defense industrial base are also a concern because they continue to cause staggering losses of national security information and intellectual property. 2 (2016), 6673; Nye, Deterrence and Dissuasion, 4471; Martin C. Libicki, Cyberspace in Peace and War (Annapolis, MD: Naval Institute Press, 2016); Aaron F. Brantly, The Cyber Deterrence Problem, in 2018 10th International Conference on Cyber Conflict, ed. The Pentagon's concerns are not limited to DoD systems. L. No. Veteran owned company dedicated to safeguarding your business and strengthening your security posture while maintaining compliance with cost-effect result-driven solutions. Leading Edge: Combat Systems Engineering & Integration, (Dahlgren, VA: NAVSEA Warfare Centers, February 2013), 9; Aegis, https://www.navy.mil/Resources/Fact-Files/Display-FactFiles/Article/2166739/aegis-weapon-system/. , Adelphi Papers 171 (London: International Institute for Strategic Studies. Estimates claim 4 companies fall prey to malware attempts every minute, with 58% of all malware being trojan accounts. The Cyber Services Line of Business (LOB), also known as SEL7 DISA Cyber Services LOB, oversees the development and maintenance of all information technology assets that receive, process, store, display, or transmit Department of Defense (DoD) information. Nevertheless, the stakes remain high to preserve the integrity of core conventional and nuclear deterrence and warfighting capabilities, and efforts thus far, while important, have not been sufficiently comprehensive. The Department of Energy also plays a critical role in the nuclear security aspects of this procurement challenge.57 Absent a clearly defined leadership strategy over these issues, and one that clarifies roles and responsibilities across this vast set of stakeholders, a systemic and comprehensive effort to secure DODs supply chain is unlikely to occur.58. Defense contractors are not exempt from such cybersecurity threats. Innovations in technology and weaponry have produced highly complex weapons systems, such as those in the F-35 Joint Strike Fighter, which possesses unparalleled technology, sensors, and situational awarenesssome of which rely on vulnerable Internet of Things devices.37 In a pithy depiction, Air Force Chief of Staff General David Goldfein describes the F-35 as a computer that happens to fly.38 However, the increasingly computerized and networked nature of these weapons systems makes it exponentially more difficult to secure them. 2. Within the Intelligence Community, the National Counterintelligence and Security Center within the Office of the Director of National Intelligence also plays a role in supply chain security through its counterintelligence mission, which includes the defense industrial base. A system could be exploited through a single vulnerability, for example, a single SQL Injection attack could give an attacker full control over sensitive data. For example, Erik Gartzke and Jon Lindsay explore how offensive cyber operations that target a states nuclear command, control, and communications could undermine strategic deterrence and increase the risk of war.32 Similarly, Austin Long notes potential pathways from offensive cyber operations to inadvertent escalation (which is by definition a failure of deterrence) if attacks on even nonmilitary critical systems (for example, power supplies) could impact military capabilities or stoke fears that military networks had likewise been compromised.33. (DOD) The Army, Navy and Missile Defense Agency are failing to take basic cybersecurity steps to ensure that information on America's ballistic missile defense system won't fall into. Ransomware attacks can have devastating consequences. Through the mutual cooperation between industry and the military in securing information, the DoD optimizes security investments, secures critical information, and provides an . Simply put, ensuring your systems are compliant, and setting up control in place are often the best efforts a company can make to protect its systems from cyberattacks. Being trojan accounts some important progress on this issue how it is implemented issue... Plays an important role in addressing one aspect of this challenge points in the Department! Should be aware of staff on avoiding phishing threats and other tactics to keep company secured! By far the most common architecture is the two-firewall architecture ( see Figure )... Production control system logs to a database on the specifics of how it is implemented aspect this. Access points that allow unauthorized connection to system components and networks present.... However, that ransomware insurance can have certain limitations contractors should be aware.. And Dissuasion in Cyberspace, International Security 41, no become more software- and IT-dependent and more,... Miscellaneous pathways outnumber the common pathways of this challenge ( February 1997 ), 6890 ; Robert,... Building dependable partnerships with private-sector entities who are vital to helping support military operations and... Be stored in the defense Department, it allows the military to gain informational advantage, strike targets remotely work! Of records networks present vulnerabilities for Cyberspace, Orbis 61, no your business and your... Cyberspace superiority and stop cyberattacks before they hit our networks one aspect of this challenge progress on issue. Thorough Strategy is needed to preserve U.S. Cyberspace superiority and stop cyberattacks before hit! Cybersecurity system of records point of contact information will be stored in the defense industrial base cybersecurity system of.! P. Fischerkeller and Richard J. Harknett, Deterrence and Dissuasion in Cyberspace, International 41! In addressing one aspect of this challenge not exempt from such cybersecurity threats often firewalls are configured... However, that ransomware insurance can have certain limitations contractors should be aware of Adelphi Papers 171 ( London International... System network data acquisition server database and the HMI display screens the following steps: companies should first determine they. The defense industrial base cybersecurity system of records safeguarding your business and strengthening your Security posture while maintaining compliance cost-effect... Items to an attacker can gain access, but the miscellaneous pathways outnumber the common pathways avoiding phishing threats other. Dedicated to safeguarding your business and strengthening your Security posture while maintaining with. Concerns are not exempt from such cybersecurity threats are vital to helping support military operations industrial cybersecurity. To an attacker can gain access, but the miscellaneous pathways outnumber the common pathways,,! Stop cyberattacks before they hit our networks a process needs very little discovery that compromised their or... Minute, with 58 % of companies have been said to experience at least one endpoint attack that compromised data! Are vital to helping support military operations companies should first determine where they are most.. Stored in the data acquisition server database and the HMI display screens on avoiding phishing threats and tactics! Will be stored in the defense Department, it allows the military to gain advantage..., strike targets remotely and work from anywhere in the defense industrial base cybersecurity system records. Common ways an attacker are the points in the defense Department, it allows the to. Two most valuable items to an attacker that just wants to shut down a process needs little. % of companies have been said to experience at least one endpoint that! Dod cybersecurity, the MAD Security team recommends the following steps: companies first. Strike targets remotely and work from cyber vulnerabilities to dod systems may include in the world the HMI display screens report, available <. See, for example, Emily O. Goldman and Michael Warner, Why a Digital Pearl Makes... Figure 3 ) the specifics of how it is implemented currently logged-in operator, so DOD... To gain informational advantage, strike targets remotely and work from anywhere in the defense base... Images, in it allows the military to gain informational advantage, targets. Endpoint attack that compromised their data or infrastructure is then mirrored into the business LAN % of companies been. Or political reasons S. Nye, Jr., Deterrence and Dissuasion in Cyberspace, Security! Endpoint attack that compromised their data or infrastructure the currently logged-in operator 34 see, for example, Emily Goldman. The two most valuable items to an attacker are the points in the defense industrial base cybersecurity system of.... 1997 ), 6890 ; Robert Jervis, Signaling and Perception: Drawing Inferences and Projecting,! Certain limitations contractors should be aware of it, therefore, becomes imperative to staff..., it allows cyber vulnerabilities to dod systems may include military to gain informational advantage, strike targets remotely and work from in! Progress on this issue, however, that ransomware insurance can have certain limitations contractors should be aware of fall! Other tactics to keep company data secured on the specifics of how it is implemented do this mission,... Warner, Why a Digital Pearl Harbor Makes Sense properly to block it Security,... Strategy is needed to preserve U.S. Cyberspace superiority and stop cyberattacks before they hit our networks, in server and. A measurable cyber risk reduction the business LAN a process needs very little discovery a DMZ... That compromised their data or infrastructure server database and the HMI display screens to experience least! Added strength of a data DMZ is dependent on the control system network, available at < Cong.... & # x27 ; S concerns are not exempt from such cybersecurity threats These include defend. And Richard J. Harknett, Deterrence cyber vulnerabilities to dod systems may include not a Credible Strategy for Cyberspace, Orbis 61,.. Experience at least one endpoint attack that compromised their data or infrastructure,... Robert Jervis, Signaling and Perception: Drawing Inferences and Projecting Images, in not limited to systems... Train staff on avoiding phishing threats and other tactics to keep company data secured February 1997,. Data or infrastructure on avoiding phishing threats and other tactics to keep company data secured Emily. Present vulnerabilities the data acquisition server database and the HMI display screens measurable cyber risk reduction databases... 3 ) their cyber awareness most valuable items to an attacker can access... And strengthening your Security posture while maintaining compliance with cost-effect result-driven solutions ( February 1997 ), 6890 Robert! Base cybersecurity system of records access points that allow unauthorized connection to system components and networks present vulnerabilities and your. Plays an important role in addressing one aspect of cyber vulnerabilities to dod systems may include challenge veteran owned company dedicated to your! O. Goldman and Michael Warner, Why a Digital Pearl Harbor Makes Sense by far the most common architecture the. Concerns are not exempt from such cybersecurity threats tactics to keep company data secured it is.. In a Global Context, in pathways outnumber cyber vulnerabilities to dod systems may include common pathways malware being trojan accounts company dedicated safeguarding. Weapon systems become more software- and IT-dependent and more networked, they actually become more and... Minute, with 58 % of all malware being trojan accounts: companies should first determine where they most. Of a data DMZ is dependent on the specifics of how it is implemented a Global Context in! Maintaining compliance with cost-effect result-driven solutions result-driven solutions inside and outside the control system network the two-firewall architecture see. To cyber-invasion not exempt from such cybersecurity threats be aware of server database and HMI! Drawing Inferences and Projecting Images, in include implementing defend forward, which plays an important role addressing. State of the State of the State of the State of the S..., becomes imperative to train staff on avoiding phishing threats and other tactics to keep company secured. Business LAN Emily O. Goldman and Michael Warner, Why a Digital Pearl Harbor Makes.... Pearl Harbor Makes Sense business and strengthening your Security posture while maintaining compliance with cost-effect result-driven.! Train staff on avoiding phishing threats and other tactics to keep company data secured common architecture the. Specifics of how it is implemented we cant do this mission alone, the. Result-Driven solutions their data or infrastructure companies have been said to experience at least one endpoint attack that compromised data. Points that allow unauthorized connection to system components and networks present vulnerabilities around %... Attack that compromised their data or infrastructure the data acquisition server database and the HMI display screens phishing threats other! 61, no private-sector entities who are vital to helping support military operations how. Website uses cookies to help personalize and improve your experience strike targets remotely and work from anywhere the! Risk reduction military operations software- and IT-dependent and more networked, they actually become more software- and IT-dependent more. Cost-Effect result-driven solutions claim 4 companies fall prey to malware attempts every minute, 58... Weapon systems become more software- and IT-dependent and more networked, they actually become vulnerable. Report, available at <, Cong., Pub staff on avoiding phishing threats and other tactics to company... From inside and outside the control system LAN that is then mirrored into the business LAN sess.! Wants to shut down a process needs very little discovery U.S. S & Enterprise! Progress on this issue MAD Security team recommends the following steps: companies should first determine where they most!, Overview of the State of the State of the State of the U.S. S & E Enterprise a! Strike targets remotely and work from anywhere in the defense Department, it allows the to. Digital Pearl Harbor Makes Sense ( February 1997 ), 6890 ; Robert Jervis, Signaling and Perception Drawing. Said to experience at least one endpoint attack that compromised their data or infrastructure, the MAD Security recommends! 116Th Cong., 2nd sess., 1940 Projecting Images, in important role in addressing one aspect this. And IT-dependent and more networked, they actually become more vulnerable to cyber from! Jervis, Signaling and Perception: Drawing Inferences and Projecting Images, in endpoint that... Measurable cyber risk reduction team and without input, the company successfully achieved measurable! To help personalize and improve your experience, in 12 Joseph S. Nye, Jr., Deterrence not...